Customer Story Ending a 15-year refractory failure cycle at a WA alumina calciner Challenge For 15 years, a calciner at a Western Australian alumina refinery has failed to reach its planned shutdown. Each campaign is planned to run 48 months. The refractory lining in one section fails at around 30 months. When a panel falls, the steel shell behind it reaches 400 to 500°C and starts to glow. Crews weld a hot box over the outside to keep people safe. It works, but it traps the heat, and the shell climbs towards the process temperature of around 1,000°C. The steel is destroyed over the vessel’s final 18 months. During the shutdown, the hot box comes off, the damaged steel is cut out and replaced, and the refractory is repaired again. A 6-week shutdown becomes 9 weeks or more, and other maintenance activities are postponed. The refinery engaged Soto directly. Shinagawa Refractories Australasia is the preferred material partner. Opportunity Over those 15 years, the client tried something different with each repair: new materials, new anchor layouts. None held. For the refinery, breaking the cycle meant predictable campaigns, shorter shutdowns and budget freed for other upgrades. Braeden Wilson puts the alternative plainly: repairing the same failure every shutdown is “just dead money.” Soto had already looked past the original brief. In 2022, the refinery asked Soto to analyse movement in the steel shell. Marius Birsanu, who led that analysis, recommended stiffening and flagged the refractory as part of the problem. The refinery did the steel works first. They helped, but the panels kept failing, and in 2026 the refinery came back to Soto for the refractory. Solution Braeden, Soto’s mechanical engineering and refractory engineering lead on the project, looked at the repair history rather than the latest failure. Laid out over the years, the pattern was clear. Fix the long wall, and the short wall failed the next campaign. Fix that, and the bullnose went, because it was now the oldest section. The walls weren’t failing separately. They were pushing on each other. Each section expands at a different rate, and the movement passes from one wall into the next, concentrating at this vessel’s unique geometry. The anchors holding each panel stretch like springs until the panel cracks, breaks up or tears free. This is called jacking, and alumina dust packing into the joints makes it happen sooner. Braeden’s call was to stop the walls interacting. The redesign isolates the walls and bullnose from each other and specifies SHIRAGUN FS70 ZR, a low-expansion fused silica hot-face refractory from Shinagawa Refractories Australasia. Expansion joints between the sections let each one move without transferring load. The design draws on Soto’s earlier calciner work for other alumina clients. Jack Brooks then took Marius’s 2022 model, updated it with the redesign and ran a comparative analysis to check the walls would behave as intended. Marius reviewed the results. The refinery approved the scope, then the advanced analysis, before any drawings were produced. [Image: model view of the redesigned walls and bullnose, with expansion joints highlighted] Benefit The comparative analysis shows reduced stress in the long and short walls, the sections that have failed most often. If the redesign performs in service as it does in the model, the refinery can expect: Campaigns that reach the planned 48 months and beyond, instead of failing at around 30. No hot boxes, and no shell steel to cut out and replace at each shutdown. Shutdowns back to their planned length, with time and budget returned to other maintenance and upgrades. The refinery also had a clear point to stop at each stage, so it committed to drawings only once the analysis backed the design. “The design and engineering that this client paid for is a small percentage of what they’re going to pay in this upcoming shutdown, let alone the 10 previous shutdowns.” Braeden Wilson, Head of Mechanical – Associate, Soto. Installation is scheduled for the January 2027 shutdown, and Soto will update this story after the first full campaign. Location Western Australia Duration Shell analysis 2022; refractory redesign 2026 Industry Alumina Services Advanced Analysis Services, Mechanical Engineering Design Soto found why 15 years of repairs hadn’t held, and designed a fix that targets the cause rather than the symptom, verified in the model before a single panel goes in. Get in touch with our team Start a conversation